APA 7 for Psycholinguistics & Syntax–Morphology
Outline: APA 7 for Psycholinguistics & Syntax–Morphology
for Phil/PhD scholars in linguistics, psycholinguistics, syntax, morphology, and language teaching
with Examples from English, Urdu, Saraiki, Punjabi, Pothwari, HindkoI & checklists, exercises, and examples
Part I. Foundations of APA & Scientific Writing in Linguistics
1: APA 7 as a Scientific Writing System
- What is APA style? Purpose & history
- Why APA is ideal for linguistics & psycholinguistics research
- APA vs MLA vs Chicago: key differences
- Cognitive & psycholinguistic perspective: clarity, consistency, reduced processing load
- How APA prevents plagiarism
Exercises: Identify APA vs non-APA citations
2: APA & Research Thinking
- APA as a thinking framework, not just formatting
- Linking theory, data, and writing
- How APA structures cognitive load for examiners
- Practical application in psycholinguistics: participant studies, linguistic data
Exercise: Map a research idea to APA structure
Part II. Core APA Skills
3: In-Text Citations
- Author-date system explained
- Paraphrasing vs quoting
- One, two, three or more authors
- Organizational authors (HEC, UNESCO, WHO)
- Secondary citations & best practices
- Common mistakes in Pakistani MPhil theses
Field-specific examples:
- Psycholinguistic experiments
- Syntax & morphology papers
- Multilingual datasets
Exercise: Convert sample sentences to APA in-text citations
4: Reference Lists
- Reference list as a research database
- Alphabetical order, italics, capitalization, spacing
- Books, journal articles, edited volumes, dissertations
- Online sources, corpora, and datasets
- Pitfalls of Google Scholar APA output
Exercise: Correct an anonymized MPhil reference list
Part III. APA for Linguistic Data
5: Syntax & Morphology Examples
- Presenting trees, dependency graphs, and sentence structures
- Morpheme segmentation, interlinear glossing
- Handling ungrammaticality (*, ??)
- Italics, quotation marks, numbered examples
- Transliteration vs translation
Languages covered: Urdu, Saraiki, Punjabi, Pothwari, Hindko
Exercise: Format 5 sample sentences in APA-compliant style
6: Psycholinguistic Experiments
- Reporting participants, materials, procedure, and results
- Tables & figures (reaction time, accuracy, frequency)
- Reporting statistics APA-style (means, SD, p-values)
- Ethical citation of instruments and stimuli
- Avoiding self-plagiarism
Exercise: Format a mini-results table from a sample psycholinguistics experiment
Part IV. Pakistani Language Context & Multilingual Issues
7: Pakistani Languages & APA
- Citing non-English sources
- Transliteration conventions
- Romanization vs native script
- Ethical citation of indigenous research
- Referencing local journals, theses, and field data
Exercise: Convert Urdu/Saraiki/Punjabi sources into APA
8: Common APA Errors in Pakistani Theses
- Over-quoting theorists
- Weak paraphrasing
- Inconsistent years & authors
- Fake or broken DOIs
- Mixing APA 6 & APA 7
- Poor abstracts & headings
Activity: Error-hunting from anonymized theses
Part V. Tools, AI & Publication Readiness
9: APA Tools & AI Assistance
- Reference managers: Zotero, Mendeley
- ChatGPT for paraphrasing & ethics
- AI risks in APA & plagiarism detection
- Human judgment vs automation
Exercise: Import, correct, and export 10 references using Zotero
10: Examiner Psychology & Publishing
- What NUML/HEC examiners check in theses
- APA mistakes that trigger revisions
- From thesis chapter to journal article
- Checklist for final submission
Exercise: Self-check your draft chapter against APA checklist
Part VI. Practice & Review
11: Integrated Practice
- Mini-thesis chapter with APA-compliant text, citations, and references
- Tables, figures, glossing examples included
- Peer-review and self-assessment exercises
12: Summary & Final Checklist
- Recap of all APA essentials
- Field-specific tips for psycholinguistics and Pakistani languages
- Ready-to-use checklist for students and scholars
APA 7 for Psycholinguistics & Syntax–Morphology
Part I. Foundations of APA & Scientific Writing in Linguistics
1. What is APA Style? Purpose & History
APA style is a set of formal guidelines for writing and citing scholarly work, developed by the American Psychological Association. It is widely used in social sciences, education, and linguistics because it emphasizes clarity, consistency, and ethical attribution of ideas.
Purpose of APA style:
- Standardizes academic writing across publications.
- Makes research clear and reproducible.
- Gives proper credit to original authors.
- Reduces ambiguity and improves readability for examiners and peer reviewers.
Brief History:
1929: First APA style guidelines published in a journal article to standardize psychological research.
1952–2019: Multiple revisions; 7th edition (2019) is current.
7th edition highlights: Simplified headings, clearer student vs professional rules, inclusion of DOIs and URLs, and guidance for citing digital and multilingual sources.
2. Why APA is Ideal for Linguistics & Psycholinguistics Research
APA style is particularly suited for linguistics because it allows scholars to:
Report experiments clearly: participant details, stimuli, procedure, and results.
Present structured linguistic data: examples, glosses, trees, and tables.
Ensure reproducibility: citations and references allow others to verify findings.
Reduce plagiarism: proper attribution of theoretical frameworks and experimental studies.
Align with cognitive science and psycholinguistics: clear structure mirrors how readers process and understand complex data.
Example (Psycholinguistic study):
Ali (2021) investigated Urdu sentence processing using eye-tracking, showing faster comprehension for canonical word orders. Proper APA citation allows readers to locate and verify the original experiment.
3. APA vs MLA vs Chicago: Key Differences
| Feature | APA | MLA | Chicago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary use | Social sciences, psychology, linguistics | Humanities, literature | History, general academia |
| In-text citation | Author–date system | Author–page system | Notes/bibliography or author–date |
| Reference list | References (alphabetical) | Works Cited | Bibliography or References |
| Emphasis | Clarity, reproducibility, concise reporting | Literary analysis | Historical sourcing, footnotes |
| Tables & figures | Standardized, numbered, labeled | Less standardized | Detailed captions |
Tip for linguists: APA works best for psycholinguistics and syntax because experiments, tables, and cross-linguistic examples need structured reporting that MLA or Chicago does not provide.
References:
American Psychological Association. (2020). Publication manual of the American Psychological Association (7th ed.). Washington, DC: Author.
Modern Language Association. (2016). MLA handbook (8th ed.). New York, NY: MLA.
Turabian, K. (2018). A manual for writers of research papers, theses, and dissertations (9th ed.). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
4. Cognitive & Psycholinguistic Perspective
APA style improves readability and processing by:
Clarity: Standard headings and citation format reduce ambiguity.
Consistency: Predictable format lets readers focus on content, not style.
Reduced cognitive load: Structured presentation of methods, data, and discussion allows examiners to evaluate work efficiently.
APA organizes it as:
(Ali, 2021; Khan, 2020; Rehman, Ahmed, & Fatima, 2019), with consistent in-text citation format and corresponding references.
5. How APA Prevents Plagiarism
In-text citations: Attribute every idea or data point to its original source.
Reference list: Provides full source details for verification.
Encourages paraphrasing: Reduces copying while maintaining integrity.
Tip: Using APA properly shows academic honesty and enhances credibility.
Exercises: Identify APA vs Non-APA Citations
Task: Review the following citations. Mark ✅ for correct APA, ❌ for incorrect APA.
(Ali, 2021) conducted a study on Urdu sentence processing. ✅
Ali (2021) did research on Urdu sentence processing. ❌ (missing proper parentheses for APA style)
(Khan & Rehman, 2020; Ali, 2021) found significant differences in comprehension. ✅
Khan & Rehman stated that sentence comprehension varies in different languages (2020). ❌ (year placement is wrong)
Reflection:
What makes a citation APA-compliant?
How does proper citation help in avoiding plagiarism?
2: APA & Research Thinking
1. APA as a Thinking Framework, Not Just Formatting
Example:
When writing a study on Saraiki plural morpheme processing, APA dictates the logical flow:
Introduction: Theoretical background (Ali, 2021; Khan, 2020)
Method: Participants, materials, procedure
Results: Tables and statistical analysis
Discussion: Interpretation and link to prior research
This structure is more than style—it mirrors scientific reasoning.
2. Linking Theory, Data, and Writing
APA style promotes clear connections between theoretical claims and empirical data:
Theory: What concepts or frameworks inform your research?
Data: What experiments, observations, or corpus evidence support your investigation?
Writing: How do you present and interpret these ideas so they are credible and reproducible?
Example:
In a psycholinguistic study on Punjabi word-order processing, theory predicts faster comprehension for canonical orders (Chomsky, 1957; Ali, 2020). Eye-tracking data show shorter fixation times on canonical sentences, confirming the theoretical expectation (Hussain, 2021).
APA ensures that the citation, result, and interpretation are seamlessly integrated, reducing ambiguity.
3. How APA Structures Cognitive Load for Examiners
APA’s standardized format reduces the mental effort required by examiners:
Headings & subheadings: Guide readers through logical sections
Tables & figures: Present complex data concisely
Consistent citation format: Helps readers verify sources quickly
Structured discussion & results: Reduces need for examiners to mentally reorganize your ideas
Psycholinguistic insight: Humans process predictable structures faster. APA leverages this principle by making academic writing intuitively navigable.
This reduces examiner cognitive load and highlights your analytical rigor.
4. Practical Application in Psycholinguistics
APA can be directly applied to experimental and observational research in linguistics:
Participant Studies:
Include age, gender, native language, number of participants
Example: “Twenty-five Saraiki speakers aged 18–25 participated in the reaction time study” (Ali, 2022).
Stimuli & Materials:
Present experimental sentences, words, or morphemes
Number and label each stimulus clearly (APA style encourages numbering examples)
Data & Tables:
Use APA 7–formatted tables for reaction times, accuracy, or frequency data
Ensure consistent labeling, units, and notes
Analysis & Interpretation:
Link results to prior research using proper in-text citations
Compare cross-linguistic data (e.g., Saraiki vs Urdu vs Punjabi)
Example:
| Sentence Type | Mean Reaction Time (ms) | SD |
|---|---|---|
| Canonical | 450 | 35 |
| Non-Canonical | 520 | 42 |
Exercise: Map a Research Idea to APA Structure
Task: Take this sample research idea:
Investigate how Hindko speakers process verb agreement in real-time reading.
Map it into APA-style sections:
Title: Real-Time Processing of Verb Agreement in Hindko Speakers
Abstract: 150–200 words summary of hypothesis, method, results, and conclusion
Introduction: Discuss theoretical background, link to previous studies (Ali, 2020; Hussain, 2021)
Method: Participants, materials (stimuli), procedure
Results: Tables/figures showing reaction times and accuracy
Discussion: Interpret results and compare with theory
References: List all cited studies in APA 7th edition format
Reflection Questions:
How does APA help organize your ideas?
How does the structured format support replication and ethical reporting?
Can you identify where citations and tables enhance clarity?
Part II. Core APA Skills
3: In-Text Citations
1. Author–Date System Explained
APA 7 uses the author–date citation system, which helps readers quickly locate sources in the reference list.
Basic format:
Parenthetical citation: (Author, Year)
Narrative citation: Author (Year)
Examples:
Parenthetical: (Ali, 2021)
Narrative: Ali (2021) investigated Saraiki sentence processing.
Purpose:
Attribute ideas properly
Connect theory, data, and analysis
Maintain clarity and reproducibility
2. Paraphrasing vs Quoting
Paraphrasing: Restate an author’s ideas in your own words. Preferred in academic writing.
Example (Urdu syntax):
Original: “Urdu exhibits head-final structures in verb phrases.” (Khan, 2019)
Paraphrase: Khan (2019) notes that Urdu verb phrases generally follow a head-final structure.
Quoting: Use exact words from the source, with page number.
Example:
“Urdu exhibits head-final structures in verb phrases” (Khan, 2019, p. 23)
Tip: Over-quoting is a common mistake in Pakistani MPhil theses. Paraphrasing demonstrates understanding and avoids plagiarism.
3. One, Two, Three or More Authors
Rules:
One author: (Ali, 2021)
Two authors: (Khan & Rehman, 2020)
Three or more authors: (Hussain et al., 2021)
Narrative form:
Ali (2021) …
Khan and Rehman (2020) …
Hussain et al. (2021) …
Example in psycholinguistics:
Reaction time studies show faster comprehension for canonical word order (Hussain et al., 2021).
4. Organizational Authors
Some studies are authored by organizations like HEC, UNESCO, or WHO. APA requires full name first, then abbreviation in parentheses for subsequent citations.
Example:
First citation: (Higher Education Commission [HEC], 2020)
Subsequent citations: (HEC, 2020)
Multilingual research:
(UNESCO, 2018) – e.g., multilingual literacy report
5. Secondary Citations & Best Practices
A secondary citation occurs when you cite a source mentioned in another source. Use sparingly.
Format: (Original Author, Year, as cited in Secondary Author, Year)
Example:
Chomsky’s theory of Universal Grammar (1957, as cited in Ali, 2020) emphasizes innate linguistic structures.
Tip: Always try to locate the original source before relying on secondary citations.
6. Common Mistakes in Pakistani MPhil Theses
- Missing years in citations
- Mixing narrative and parenthetical styles incorrectly
- Overusing quotations instead of paraphrasing
- Inconsistent author lists for multiple authors
- Citing sources not listed in the reference list
Example of common error:
Ali, Khan & Rehman 2020 ❌
Correct: (Ali, Khan, & Rehman, 2020) ✅
7. Field-Specific Examples
Psycholinguistic experiments:
- Parenthetical: (Ali, 2021; Hussain et al., 2021)
- Narrative: Ali (2021) found… Hussain et al. (2021) confirmed…
Syntax & morphology papers:
- Discussing agreement patterns: (Khan, 2019; Malik, 2020)
Multilingual datasets:
- Cross-linguistic comparisons: (Hussain et al., 2021; Ali & Rehman, 2020)
Tip: Use semicolons for multiple sources in a single parenthetical citation, alphabetized by author surname.
8. Exercise: Convert Sample Sentences to APA In-Text Citations
Task: Rewrite the following sentences in proper APA 7 in-text format:
- Ali conducted a study on Saraiki plural morphemes in 2021.
- Khan and Rehman studied Urdu sentence processing in 2020.
- Hussain, Ahmed, and Fatima investigated Punjabi syntax in 2021.
- Chomsky’s 1957 theory is discussed in Ali 2020.
- UNESCO (2018) published a multilingual literacy report.
Answer Key:
- (Ali, 2021)
- (Khan & Rehman, 2020)
- (Hussain et al., 2021)
- Chomsky’s theory of Universal Grammar (1957, as cited in Ali, 2020)
- (UNESCO, 2018)
Reflection Questions:
- Which sentences use narrative form?
- How do you handle more than three authors?
- How does APA improve clarity for cross-linguistic research?
- Apply the author–date system correctly for one, two, or multiple authors
- Distinguish between paraphrasing and quoting
- Handle organizational and secondary citations
- Avoid common citation mistakes in Pakistani MPhil theses
- Implement APA citations in psycholinguistic, syntactic, and multilingual research
4: Reference Lists
1. Reference List as a Research Database
A reference list is not just a formality, it is a research database that allows readers to:
- Verify your sources
- Trace the origin of theories, methods, and findings
- Explore related research for further study
In linguistics, especially psycholinguistics, a well-formatted reference list ensures that:
- Experimental results can be cross-checked
- Language-specific examples (Urdu, Saraiki, Punjabi, Pothwari, Hindko) are clearly cited
- Multilingual or cross-linguistic research remains transparent
Example:
Ali, S. (2021). Real-time sentence processing in Saraiki speakers. Islamabad: National Linguistics Press.
2. Alphabetical Order, Italics, Capitalization, Spacing
APA 7 rules for reference lists:
- Alphabetical by first author’s surnameHanging indent: First line flush left, subsequent lines indented 0.5 inch
- Italics: Book titles, journal names, volume numbers
- Capitalization:Sentence case for titles: Real-time sentence processing in Saraiki speakers
- Title case for journals: Journal of Psycholinguistic Research
- Spacing: Double-space all entries
Example of Proper Formatting:
Journal article:
Hussain, R., Ahmed, F., & Malik, T. (2021). Verb agreement processing in Punjabi. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 50(3), 245–260. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10936-021-09789-2
Book:
Khan, A. (2019). Urdu syntax: Morphology and sentence structure. Lahore: Linguistics Press.
Edited volume chapter:
Rehman, S. (2020). Morphological patterns in Hindko. In M. Ali & T. Malik (Eds.), Studies in South Asian linguistics (pp. 45–67). Islamabad: National Linguistics Press.
3. Types of Sources
Books: Full title italicized, publisher included.
Journal Articles: Italicize journal name and volume; include DOI if available.
Edited Volumes / Chapters: Include editors (Eds.), book title, page range.
Dissertations / Theses:
Ali, S. (2020). Syntax acquisition in Saraiki children (Unpublished MPhil thesis). National University of Modern Languages, Islamabad.
Online Sources / Corpora / Datasets: Include URL or DOI:
Hussain, R. (2021). Saraiki morphosyntactic corpus [Dataset]. https://doi.org/10.1234/smc2021
4. Pitfalls of Google Scholar APA Output
Google Scholar often misformats author lists, capitalization, or italics
DOI may be missing or incorrect
Multiple authors may be truncated incorrectly
Always verify each reference manually against APA 7 rules
Example of common Google Scholar error:
Hussain, R et al 2021 verb agreement processing in punjabi journal of psycholinguistic research 50(3) 245-260
Corrected APA 7 version:
Hussain, R., Ahmed, F., & Malik, T. (2021). Verb agreement processing in Punjabi. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 50(3), 245–260. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10936-021-09789-2
5. Exercise: Correct an Anonymized MPhil Reference List
Task: Fix the errors in the following list according to APA 7:
- Ali S 2021 Real time sentence processing in Saraiki speakers Islamabad National Linguistics Press
- Khan A 2019 Urdu Syntax: Morphology and Sentence Structure Lahore Linguistics Press
- Hussain R, Ahmed F, Malik T 2021 Verb agreement processing in Punjabi Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 50(3) 245-260
Answer Key:
- Ali, S. (2021). Real-time sentence processing in Saraiki speakers. Islamabad: National Linguistics Press.
- Khan, A. (2019). Urdu syntax: Morphology and sentence structure. Lahore: Linguistics Press.
- Hussain, R., Ahmed, F., & Malik, T. (2021). Verb agreement processing in Punjabi. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 50(3), 245–260. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10936-021-09789-2
Reflection Questions:
- Which formatting rules did you apply?
- How does APA formatting improve the readability and credibility of your thesis?
- How would you handle a dataset or online corpus in the reference list?
- Understand the reference list as a research database
- Apply APA 7 rules for books, journals, chapters, theses, and datasets
- Correct common errors in Pakistani MPhil reference lists
- Avoid relying solely on Google Scholar outputs
- Ensure clarity, reproducibility, and academic integrity in references
Part III. APA for Linguistic Data
5: Syntax & Morphology Examples in APA 7
1. Presenting Trees, Dependency Graphs, and Sentence Structures
In linguistics, visual representation of syntax is essential for clarity. APA 7 allows clear labeling and referencing of figures.
Key Guidelines:
- Number all figures sequentially (Figure 1, Figure 2, etc.)
- Provide descriptive captions
- Cite sources if trees/graphs are adapted from previous work
Example – Syntax Tree (Urdu sentence):
Sentence:
Ali ne kitaab parhi.
(Ali-ERG book read-PERF)
APA Figure Caption:
Figure 1. Syntax tree for the Urdu sentence Ali ne kitaab parhi (adapted from Khan, 2019).
Tip: Use consistent font and line thickness; APA requires figures to be legible and self-explanatory.
2. Morpheme Segmentation and Interlinear Glossing
Interlinear glossing is widely used in morphology to show word structure and meaning.
APA Guidelines:
- Use italics for native words
- Number examples sequentially: (1), (2), etc.
- Align morphemes and glosses clearly
Example – Saraiki Verb:
maiN khānā khā-iyā
1SG.NOM food eat-PERF
“I ate the food.”
Note: Italicize the original words (maiN, khānā, khā-iyā), leave gloss and translation in plain text.
3. Handling Ungrammaticality
- Use “*” for ungrammatical sentences
- Use “??” for marginally acceptable or questionable sentences
- Include a note in caption or text to explain notation
Example – Punjabi Sentence:
- *Mujhe kal bazaar gaya.
- Ungrammatical: 1SG.ACC yesterday market go-PAST
- ??O ladka kitaab parhda hai.
- Marginally acceptable: He boy book reads AUX
APA Tip: Explain symbols in figure notes or within the text.
4. Italics, Quotation Marks, and Numbered Examples
- Italics: Use for words in original language (kitaab, khānā)
- Quotation marks: Use for glosses or literal translation only when necessary
- Numbering examples: (1), (2), (3)… sequentially for easy referencing in text
Example – Numbered Syntax Example (Hindko):
Main kitaab parhi.
1SG.NOM book read-PERF
“I read the book.”
Tu khānā khā.
2SG.NOM food eat-IMP
“You eat the food.”
Reference in text: “As shown in examples (1) and (2), Hindko exhibits SOV order consistently.”
5. Transliteration vs Translation
- Transliteration: Represent native script in Latin letters (MaiN kitab parh rahaa huuN)
- Translation: Provide meaning in English (“I am reading a book”)
- APA Tip: Always include both for clarity in multilingual research
Example – Saraiki:
- Transliteration: MaiN kitaab parh rahaa huuN
- Gloss: 1SG.NOM book read-PROG be-PRS
- Translation: “I am reading a book.”
- APA-style sentence in text: MaiN kitaab parh rahaa huuN (1SG.NOM book read-PROG be-PRS, “I am reading a book”) demonstrates progressive aspect in Saraiki.
- Urdu, Saraiki, Punjabi, Pothwari, Hindko
- Ensure consistent formatting across languages
- Use native orthography for clarity when necessary, but provide transliteration and translation
7. Exercise: Format 5 Sample Sentences in APA-Compliant Style
Task: Convert the following sentences into APA 7–compliant examples with numbering, italics, glossing, and translation.
Sentences (to format):
- Ali ne kitaab parhi (Urdu)
- MaiN kitaab parh rahaa huuN (Saraiki)
- Tu khānā khā (Punjabi)
- O ladka kitaab parhda hai (Punjabi – marginal)
- Main kitaab likh raha hoon (Hindko)
Example Solution:
Ali ne kitaab parhi.
Ali-ERG book read-PERF
“Ali read the book.”
MaiN kitaab parh rahaa huuN.
1SG.NOM book read-PROG be-PRS
“I am reading a book.”
Tu khānā khā.
2SG.NOM food eat-IMP
“You eat the food.”
??O ladka kitaab parhda hai.
He boy book reads AUX
“The boy reads the book.” (marginal acceptability)
Main kitaab likh raha hoon.
1SG.NOM book write-PROG be-PRS
“I am writing a book.”
Reflection Questions:
- Did you italicize native words consistently?
- Did you number examples sequentially?
- How does glossing improve clarity for cross-linguistic readers?
- Are marginal/ungrammatical sentences clearly marked?
Outcome:
By the end of this chapter, learners will:
- Present syntax trees, dependency graphs, and sentence structures in APA 7 format
- Use morpheme segmentation and interlinear glossing properly
- Handle ungrammatical and marginal sentences clearly
- Apply italics, quotation marks, and numbering rules consistently
- Format Urdu, Saraiki, Punjabi, Pothwari, Hindko sentences for academic writing
Exercise: Format 5 Sample Sentences in APA Style
Sentences (to format):
- Ali ne kitaab parhi (Urdu)
- MaiN kitaab parh rahaa huuN (Saraiki)
- Tu khānā khā (Punjabi)
- O ladka kitaab parhda hai (Punjabi – marginal)
- Main kitaab likh raha hoon (Hindko)
APA-Compliant Formatting Solution
(1) Urdu – Canonical sentence
Ali ne kitaab parhi.
Ali-ERG book read-PERF
“Ali read the book.”
APA Tips Applied Here
Italicization: Native words (Ali, kitaab, parhi) are italicized.
Numbering: Examples are sequentially numbered (1–5) for reference in text.
Glossing: Interlinear morpheme-by-morpheme gloss provided under each native sentence.
Translation: English translation in quotation marks under gloss.
Ungrammaticality: Marginal or ungrammatical sentences marked with * or ?? and explained in parentheses.
Reflection Questions for Students:
- Why is numbering important for referencing multiple examples in a paper?
- How does glossing improve understanding for cross-linguistic readers?
- What symbols indicate ungrammaticality or marginality, and why are they needed?
- How do italics and quotation marks enhance APA-compliant clarity?
6: Psycholinguistic Experiments in APA 7
1. Reporting Participants, Materials, Procedure, and Results
In psycholinguistics, APA 7 emphasizes clear, reproducible reporting. Standard sections include:
Participants:
- Number, age, gender, language background, selection criteria
- Example:
- Twenty-five Saraiki-speaking university students (ages 18–25, 12 male, 13 female) participated voluntarily in the study (Ali, 2021).
- Linguistic stimuli, tasks, experimental software, or datasets
- Example:
- Stimuli consisted of 40 Urdu sentences varying in word order (SOV vs OSV), presented using PsychoPy software (Peirce et al., 2019).
- Step-by-step description to allow replication
- Example:
- Participants read sentences on a computer screen while their eye movements were recorded. Each trial lasted 5 seconds.
- Present data in tables, figures, or descriptive statistics
- Include mean, SD, p-values for quantitative data
2. Tables & Figures
APA 7 allows clear presentation of psycholinguistic results:
Table Guidelines:
- Number tables sequentially: Table 1, Table 2…
- Include title in italics
- Include units and brief notes if needed
Example Table – Reaction Time (Saraiki SOV vs OSV):
| Sentence Type | Mean RT (ms) | SD |
|---|---|---|
| SOV | 450 | 35 |
| OSV | 520 | 42 |
Figure Guidelines:
- Number figures: Figure 1, Figure 2…
- Provide descriptive captions and legends
- Cite source if adapted
Example – Eye-tracking Figure Caption:
Figure 1. Fixation durations for SOV vs OSV sentences in Saraiki participants (adapted from Ali, 2021).
3. Reporting Statistics APA-Style
Descriptive Statistics:
- Mean (M) and standard deviation (SD)
- Example: Reaction times for SOV sentences were faster (M = 450 ms, SD = 35) than OSV sentences (M = 520 ms, SD = 42).
Inferential Statistics:
Include test type, test statistic, df, and p-value
Example:
A paired-samples t-test indicated a significant difference between SOV and OSV sentences, t(24) = 4.56, p < .001.
Tip: Always report effect size when possible (Cohen’s d, η²).
4. Ethical Citation of Instruments and Stimuli
Cite software, experimental paradigms, corpora, or datasets
Avoid using materials without permission or proper attribution
Examples:
- PsychoPy software: (Peirce et al., 2019)
- Saraiki corpus: (Hussain, 2021)
- Urdu sentence stimuli adapted from Khan (2019)
5. Avoiding Self-Plagiarism
Do not reuse your previous work without citation
Rewriting prior analyses is acceptable if clearly referenced
Example:
Previous reaction time data were reported in Ali (2020); current study extends findings with new stimuli.
6. Exercise: Format a Mini-Results Table
Task: Format the following reaction time data in APA-compliant style:
| Sentence Type | RT (ms) |
|---|---|
| SVO | 480 |
| VSO | 530 |
| OVS | 560 |
Solution:
| Sentence Type | Mean RT (ms) | SD |
|---|---|---|
| SVO | 480 | 30 |
| VSO | 530 | 28 |
| OVS | 560 | 35 |
Table 2Mean reaction times (RT) and standard deviations (SD) for Urdu sentences with different word orders.
Reflection Questions:
- How do tables improve clarity and reduce examiner cognitive load?
- Why is it important to report both mean and SD?
- How should you cite the source of stimuli or software in the results section?
Outcome:
By the end of this chapter, learners will be able to:
- Report participants, materials, procedures, and results APA-style
- Format tables and figures for reaction time, accuracy, or frequency data
- Report descriptive and inferential statistics correctly
- Cite instruments, stimuli, and datasets ethically
- Avoid self-plagiarism in reporting experimental data
Part IV. Pakistani Language Context & Multilingual Issues
7: Pakistani Languages & APA
1. Citing Non-English Sources
When citing sources in Urdu, Saraiki, Punjabi, Pothwari, or Hindko:
Include the original language title and provide English translation in brackets
Include Romanized transliteration if the script is non-Latin
Example (Urdu book):
Khan, A. (2019). Urdu syntax: Morfoloji aur jumlay ka dhanchaa [Urdu syntax: Morphology and sentence structure]. Lahore: Linguistics Press.
Example (Saraiki article):
Ali, S. (2020). Saraiki jumlay di samajh [Understanding Saraiki sentences]. Journal of South Asian Linguistics, 5(2), 45–60.
Tip: APA allows original language titles, but English translation helps international readers.
2. Transliteration Conventions
Romanization is often required when:
Original script is Arabic-based (Urdu, Saraiki, Punjabi)
Readers may not read native script
Guidelines:
Use consistent Romanization across the manuscript
Use diacritics sparingly for phonetic clarity
Italicize transliterated words
Example:
MaiN kitaab parh rahaa huuN (I am reading a book)
3. Romanization vs Native Script
Options:
Romanization only: Useful for international audiences
Native script with transliteration in parentheses: Ideal for bilingual readership
Native script in text, Romanized in reference list: Ensures APA-compliant reference list
Example in-text:
Native script: میں کتاب پڑھ رہا ہوں (MaiN kitaab parh rahaa huuN)
Translation: “I am reading a book.”
Reference list (APA 7):
Hussain, R. (2021). MaiN kitaab parh rahaa huuN [I am reading a book]. Islamabad: National Linguistics Press.
4. Ethical Citation of Indigenous Research
- Always cite fieldwork, interviews, local datasets, or unpublished theses
- Provide clear attribution for indigenous knowledge
- Avoid paraphrasing sensitive information without permission
Example:
Data from Saraiki-speaking participants were collected during fieldwork in Multan (Ali, 2022, unpublished field notes).
5. Referencing Local Journals, Theses, and Field Data
Local Journals:
- Follow APA format for journals; include issue, volume, pages, and DOI if available
- Example:
- Rehman, S. (2020). Saraiki morphosyntax: A descriptive study. Multan Linguistics Journal, 12(1), 23–40.
- Include university and degree type
Example:
Ali, S. (2021). Syntax acquisition in Saraiki children (Unpublished MPhil thesis). National University of Modern Languages, Islamabad.
Field Data:
Cite as unpublished dataset or field notes
Example:
Hussain, R. (2021). Saraiki morphosyntactic corpus [Dataset]. Islamabad: National Linguistics Lab.
6. Exercise: Convert Urdu/Saraiki/Punjabi Sources into APA
Task: Format the following sources in APA 7:
- کتاب: اردو گرامر، از احمد خان، لاہور 2019
- Article: “سرائیکی فاعل فعل کا مطالعہ”، علی 2020، جرنل آف ساؤتھ ایشین لسانیات 5(2): 45–60
- Thesis: پنجاب یونیورسٹی، 2021، سرائیکی جملے کی پروسیسنگ، حسن حسین
Answer Key:
- Khan, A. (2019). Urdu grammar [Urdu grammar]. Lahore: Linguistics Press.
- Ali, S. (2020). Saraiki faa’il–fail ka mutaala [Study of Saraiki subject–verb]. Journal of South Asian Linguistics, 5(2), 45–60.
- Hussain, H. (2021). Saraiki jumlay ki processing [Processing of Saraiki sentences] (Unpublished MPhil thesis). University of Punjab, Lahore.
Reflection Questions:
- Why is it important to include both original language and English translation?
- How does APA style ensure ethically citing local knowledge?
- When should Romanization be used instead of native script?
Outcome:
By the end of this chapter, learners will be able to:
- Cite non-English sources correctly in APA 7
- Apply Romanization and transliteration conventions consistently
- Reference local journals, theses, and field data ethically
- Format multilingual sources for cross-linguistic clarity
- Ensure ethically sound and APA-compliant references for Pakistani languages
8: Common APA Errors in Pakistani Theses
1. Over-Quoting Theorists
Issue: Many students rely too heavily on direct quotations instead of paraphrasing.
Problems:
- Reduces originality
- Makes writing look patchy
- May indicate lack of understanding
Example – Over-quoting:
“Urdu exhibits head-final structures in verb phrases” (Khan, 2019, p. 23).
“Saraiki SOV order is canonical” (Ali, 2020, p. 45).
APA 7 Fix: Paraphrase while retaining attribution:
Khan (2019) notes that Urdu verb phrases generally follow a head-final structure, and Ali (2020) confirms that SOV is canonical in Saraiki.
2. Weak Paraphrasing
Issue: Changing only a few words from the original text is not true paraphrasing.
Example – Weak paraphrase:
Original: Punjabi word order influences sentence comprehension.
Weak: Punjabi sentence structure influences understanding of sentences.
APA 7 Fix: Fully rephrase, integrate, and cite:
Comprehension in Punjabi is affected by its typical word order (Hussain, 2021).
3. Inconsistent Years & Authors
Common mistakes:
- Citing the same source with different years
- Mixing authors’ names inconsistently
- Using et al. incorrectly
Example – Error:
(Ali, 2019) … (Ali, 2020) … (Ali et al., 2019)
APA 7 Fix: Verify original publication year and apply author–date rules consistently.
4. Fake or Broken DOIs
Issue: Many Pakistani theses include DOIs copied from Google without verification.
APA 7 Fix:
Verify DOI via https://doi.org
If DOI is unavailable, use stable URL or database link
Example:
Hussain, R., Ahmed, F., & Malik, T. (2021). Verb agreement processing in Punjabi. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 50(3), 245–260. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10936-021-09789-2
5. Mixing APA 6 & APA 7
Problem: Students sometimes mix rules from APA 6 (e.g., “et al.” usage, running head, citation punctuation).
Key APA 7 Differences:
- 3+ authors always use et al. in parenthetical and narrative citations after first citation
- Running head simplified for student papers
- Up to 20 authors listed in reference list before using et al.
6. Poor Abstracts & Headings
Issues:
Abstracts too long/short or missing keywords
Headings inconsistent: APA 7 specifies 5 levels of headings
Example – Poor headings:
Introduction
Methods
Results
Discussion
APA 7 Fix:
Use proper heading levels for subsections (bold, italic, title case as per level)
Abstract: concise (150–250 words), structured, with keywords
7. Activity: Error-Hunting from Anonymized Theses
Task: Students receive anonymized thesis excerpts containing APA mistakes. Identify and correct them.
Sample Excerpt (with errors):
“Saraiki SOV order is canonical” (Ali 2019) … Hussain et al 2021 … Reaction times were faster (Hussain 2020, p. 34) … DOI: 10.0000/xyz
Corrected Version:
Ali (2019) confirms that SOV is canonical in Saraiki. Reaction times were faster (Hussain et al., 2021, p. 34). DOI verified: https://doi.org/10.1000/xyz
Reflection Questions:
- Which errors affected clarity or credibility?
- How does consistent APA usage help readers and examiners?
- Which mistakes are most common in Pakistani MPhil theses?
Outcome:
By the end of this chapter, learners will:
- Identify and correct over-quoting and weak paraphrasing
- Ensure consistent years, author names, and et al. usage
- Verify DOIs and URLs for reliability
- Avoid mixing APA 6 and APA 7 styles
- Create well-structured abstracts and headings
- Develop skills for error-hunting and self-editing
Part V. Tools, AI & Publication Readiness
9: APA Tools & AI Assistance
1. Reference Managers: Zotero, Mendeley
Purpose: Reference managers help organize, format, and export references in APA 7 style.
Zotero:
- Free, open-source, supports multiple languages
- Collect references from databases, websites, or PDFs
- Automatically generate in-text citations and reference lists in APA 7
Mendeley:
- Desktop and web-based, also supports PDFs and annotations
- Integration with Word/LibreOffice for automatic citations
- Import references from online journals or Google Scholar
Tip: Always verify auto-generated APA formatting, especially for multilingual or non-English sources.
2. ChatGPT for Paraphrasing & Ethics
Use Cases:
- Generating clearer sentences from complex theory
- Summarizing psycholinguistic studies or field data
- Formatting examples for multilingual sources
Ethical Guidelines:
- Never use AI to produce original research
- Always check AI-generated text for accuracy, clarity, and APA compliance
- Paraphrase AI suggestions further to ensure your own voice
Example:
Original: “Saraiki SOV order is canonical.”
ChatGPT suggestion: “In Saraiki, the canonical word order places the subject before the object and verb.”
Final APA-compliant in-text: Ali (2020) notes that Saraiki typically follows an SOV word order.
3. AI Risks in APA & Plagiarism Detection
Potential Risks:
- AI may misattribute sources or generate fake DOIs
- Overreliance can lead to accidental plagiarism
- Citation formats may be inconsistent or outdated
Mitigation:
- Always cross-check references manually
- Use plagiarism detection tools (Turnitin, iThenticate)
- Maintain a personal log of sources and URLs
4. Human Judgment vs Automation
Automation tools save time but cannot replace critical judgment:
| Task | Automation | Human Judgment |
|---|---|---|
| Paraphrasing | ChatGPT, Grammarly | Ensure meaning retained, context correct |
| Reference Formatting | Zotero, Mendeley | Check multilingual sources, DOI accuracy |
| Plagiarism Detection | Turnitin | Interpret matches, apply citation ethics |
Rule of Thumb: Use tools for efficiency, human judgment for accuracy and ethics.
5. Exercise: Import, Correct, and Export 10 References Using Zotero
Task:
Collect 10 references (books, journal articles, theses, datasets) related to Urdu, Saraiki, Punjabi, Pothwari, Hindko linguistics.
Import into Zotero.
Verify APA 7 formatting:
Authors, year, title, italics, capitalization
Transliteration and translation for non-English titles
DOIs and URLs
Export reference list in APA 7 format.
Compare exported list with manually corrected version.
Reflection Questions:
- Which references required manual correction after export?
- How does Zotero handle non-English titles and transliteration?
- How can AI assist without replacing your judgment in citation management?
Outcome:
By the end of this chapter, learners will:
- Use reference managers (Zotero, Mendeley) for efficient APA 7 compliance
- Apply ChatGPT ethically for paraphrasing and formatting
- Understand AI risks in plagiarism and citation errors
- Integrate human judgment with automated tools
- Prepare a ready-to-submit reference list for multilingual linguistics research
10: Examiner Psychology & Publishing
1. What NUML/HEC Examiners Check in Theses
Examiners focus on both content and presentation. Key aspects include:
- Clarity of research problem and objectives
- Logical flow: Introduction → Literature → Methods → Results → Discussion
- APA 7 compliance: citations, references, tables, figures
- Originality: minimal plagiarism, proper paraphrasing, accurate attribution
- Language and style: grammar, terminology, consistency in transliteration
- Data reporting: accuracy in statistics, tables, and figures
Tip: Examiners often scan for APA compliance first, then evaluate content rigor.
2. APA Mistakes That Trigger Revisions
Common APA issues that delay thesis approval:
- Over-quoting or weak paraphrasing
- Inconsistent author names or years
- Incorrect or missing DOIs/URLs
- Improper formatting of tables, figures, and headings
- Unmarked marginal/ungrammatical sentences in syntax/morphology
- Poorly formatted abstracts or missing keywords
- Mixing APA 6 and APA 7 rules
Tip: Minor APA errors can trigger full revision requests in NUML/HEC evaluation.
3. From Thesis Chapter to Journal Article
Steps to transform a chapter into a publishable article:
- Condense literature review: Focus on relevant references
- Highlight key findings: Use tables/figures for clarity
- Use journal-specific APA format: Check author guidelines
- Emphasize contribution: Stress novelty, especially for Pakistani languages or multilingual datasets
- Ethics and citations: Maintain proper credit for all stimuli, corpora, or fieldwork
Example:
Thesis chapter on Saraiki SOV sentence processing → journal article in Journal of Psycholinguistic Research
Include concise introduction, methods, results, discussion, and APA-compliant references
4. Checklist for Final Submission
| Section | APA Checkpoints |
|---|---|
| Title Page | Correct running head, title, author info |
| Abstract | 150–250 words, keywords included, structured |
| Introduction | Clear problem statement, properly cited |
| Literature Review | Paraphrased, consistent references, APA-compliant |
| Methods | Participants, materials, procedure, statistical reporting APA-style |
| Results | Tables & figures numbered, captions, statistics reported |
| Discussion | Accurate citations, interpret results without over-quoting |
| References | Alphabetical, italicization, DOI/URLs verified, transliteration & translation for non-English |
| Appendices | Proper labeling, numbering, and referencing in text |
| General | Grammar, headings, marginal/ungrammatical sentence marking, plagiarism check |
5. Exercise: Self-Check Your Draft Chapter Against APA Checklist
Task:
Take one chapter of your thesis.
Use the APA checklist above to review:
Citations and references
Tables, figures, and statistical reporting
Headings and formatting
Transliteration, translation, and multilingual consistency
Abstract and keywords
Mark all corrections and revise accordingly
Reflection Questions:
Which APA errors are most frequent in your draft?
Did tables, figures, and glossed examples follow APA 7 style?
Are all multilingual sources properly transliterated and translated?
How can you improve clarity and readability for examiners?
Outcome:
By the end of this chapter, learners will:
Understand what NUML/HEC examiners prioritize
Identify APA mistakes that trigger revisions
Convert thesis chapters into journal-ready APA articles
Use a comprehensive final submission checklist
Conduct a self-assessment to ensure APA-compliant, publication-ready work
Part VI. Practice & Review
11: Integrated Practice – Putting APA into Action
1. Mini-Thesis Chapter Example
Purpose: Apply all APA 7 principles—citations, references, tables, figures, glossing, transliteration, and multilingual examples—in one integrated chapter.
Sample Mini-Chapter:
Title: Sentence Processing in Saraiki and Urdu: A Psycholinguistic Study
2. Tables & Figures Example
Table 1 – Reaction Times (ms) for Sentence Types
| Language | Sentence Type | Mean RT | SD |
|---|---|---|---|
| Saraiki | SOV | 455 | 34 |
| Saraiki | OSV | 518 | 41 |
| Urdu | SOV | 462 | 36 |
| Urdu | VSO | 525 | 39 |
Note. Reaction times (RT) measured in milliseconds. Canonical sentences processed faster in both languages.
Figure 1 – Syntax Tree Example
Figure caption: Syntax tree for Saraiki sentence MaiN kitaab parh rahaa huuN (Ali, 2020).
3. Glossed Example
4. References (APA 7)
Ali, S. (2020). Saraiki jumlay di samajh [Understanding Saraiki sentences]. Journal of South Asian Linguistics, 5(2), 45–60.
Hussain, R. (2021). Saraiki morphosyntactic corpus [Dataset]. Islamabad: National Linguistics Lab.
Khan, A. (2019). Urdu syntax: Morfoloji aur jumlay ka dhanchaa [Urdu syntax: Morphology and sentence structure]. Lahore: Linguistics Press.
5. Peer-Review and Self-Assessment Exercises
Activity 1 – Peer Review:
- Exchange mini-chapter drafts with a colleague.
- Check for APA compliance: citations, references, tables, figures, transliteration, glossing, statistical reporting.
- Provide feedback on clarity, consistency, and ethics.
Activity 2 – Self-Assessment:
Use the final APA checklist (Chapter 10) to review your own draft.
Identify errors in:
In-text citations
Reference list
Table/figure formatting
Multilingual source handling
Abstract, headings, and overall readability
Reflection Questions:
- Did your tables and figures comply with APA numbering and captions?
- Were non-English sources properly transliterated and translated?
- Did the mini-chapter reflect ethical citation and plagiarism avoidance?
- How effectively does the mini-chapter integrate syntax, morphology, and psycholinguistic data?
Outcome:
By completing this chapter, learners will:
- Integrate all APA 7 skills into a single, coherent mini-thesis chapter
- Apply tables, figures, glossing, and transliteration effectively
- Conduct peer-review and self-assessment for quality and APA compliance
- Build confidence for MPhil thesis writing and journal publication
12: Summary & Final Checklist
1. Recap of All APA Essentials
This chapter consolidates the key APA 7 principles covered in previous chapters:
Writing & Formatting:
APA is not just formatting; it structures thinking and reduces cognitive load for examiners.
Use consistent headings, numbering, italics, and transliteration.
Citations & References:
In-text: Author–date system, et al. rules, paraphrasing over quoting.
Reference list: Alphabetical, italics, capitalization, DOI/URL verification, transliteration and English translation for non-English sources.
Tables & Figures:
Number sequentially, provide descriptive captions, report statistics clearly.
Use glossing, morpheme segmentation, and syntactic trees with APA-compliant formatting.
Multilingual & Field-Specific Practices:
Pakistani languages: Urdu, Saraiki, Punjabi, Pothwari, Hindko.
Transliteration vs native script, ethical citation of fieldwork and datasets.
Psycholinguistic Research Reporting:
Participants, materials, procedures, reaction times, accuracy, statistical reporting (M, SD, p-values).
Ethical citation of instruments and stimuli.
Avoid self-plagiarism.
Common Pitfalls:
Over-quoting, weak paraphrasing, inconsistent years/authors, broken DOIs, mixing APA 6 & 7, poor abstracts/headings.
Examiners often focus on APA compliance first; errors can trigger revisions.
Tools & AI:
Zotero, Mendeley, and ChatGPT can assist but require human judgment for accuracy and ethics.
AI risks: misattribution, fake DOIs, plagiarism; always verify outputs.
2. Field-Specific Tips for Psycholinguistics & Pakistani Languages
Syntax & Morphology: Mark ungrammatical/marginal sentences (*, ??), gloss consistently, italicize native words.
Multilingual Research: Provide transliteration + English translation, ensure uniform style across Urdu, Saraiki, Punjabi, Pothwari, Hindko.
Psycholinguistic Experiments: Use APA-compliant tables/figures for reaction times, accuracy, and cross-linguistic comparisons.
Corpus & Field Data: Cite indigenous research ethically, document fieldwork, and reference local journals/theses properly.
3. Ready-to-Use APA Checklist for Students and Scholars
Writing & Formatting
- Headings follow APA 7 levels
- Text is clear, consistent, and structured
- Italics and quotation marks used correctly
- Marginal/ungrammatical sentences marked (*, ??)
Citations & References
- In-text citations follow author–date format
- Paraphrasing preferred over direct quotes
- Reference list alphabetized, italics correct, DOIs/URLs verified
- Non-English sources transliterated + translated
- Theses, datasets, and field data cited ethically
Tables & Figures
- Numbered sequentially
- Descriptive captions included
- Statistics (M, SD, p-values) reported correctly
- Figures/tables self-explanatory
Psycholinguistic & Linguistic Data
- Participants, materials, procedures described clearly
- Stimuli and instruments cited ethically
- Reaction times, comprehension, and other measurements reported APA-style
- Syntax/morphology examples formatted with glossing and translation
Tools & AI
- Zotero/Mendeley used for reference management
- ChatGPT/paraphrasing tools used ethically
- Human judgment applied to check formatting, citations, and plagiarism
Final Checks
- Abstract 150–250 words, structured, keywords included
- Consistency across chapters (APA 7 compliance)
- Plagiarism check complete
- Ready for submission or journal publication
Outcome:
By completing this chapter, learners will:
- Have a concise summary of all APA essentials relevant to linguistics, psycholinguistics, and Pakistani languages.
- Be able to self-assess using a practical checklist before submission.
- Gain confidence for thesis completion, journal publication, and ethical academic writing.
Explore more
