With the Supreme Court's recent order to serve letters to respondents in a case contesting the notification, the ongoing situation around the postponement of elections in Punjab and KPK has been making headlines in Pakistan. The formal and legalistic nature of the issue and the Supreme Court's role in resolving it will be reflected in this blog post's analysis of the linguistic elements and discourse techniques utilized in the news piece.
To begin with, the news reports make use of formal language and legal jargon, including "petition," "respondents," and "challenging the notification." These linguistic features emphasize the formal processes and vocabulary employed in legal problems, highlighting the juridical and technical aspects of the topic. This reflects the gravity of the situation and the requirement for legal knowledge and power to handle it.
Second, the sentence "notices were served to respondents" in the news item uses the passive voice. By putting the emphasis on the action rather than the actor, this linguistic element may minimize the role played by the Supreme Court in settling the situation. It also highlights the formal and procedural aspects of the court's ruling, emphasizing the importance of due process and the validity of the law.
Thirdly. the news is more credible and authentic since it includes actual comments from the petitioners and respondents. By hearing directly from the sides, readers can get a sense of the divergent points of view and interests that are at stake in the issue. While the quotes are mostly from legal officials and experts, this feature further emphasizes the importance of legal authority and knowledge in resolving the situation.
Fourthly, the phrase "challenging the notification" from the news story uses nominalization. By transforming a verb into a noun and emphasizing the action, this linguistic device draws attention to the formal and technical nature of the problem. Yet, nominalization might obfuscate the action and make it less accessible to non-experts, which may limit the public's comprehension and engagement with the situation.
The formal and legalistic nature of the issue and the Supreme Court's role in resolving it are reflected overall in the linguistic aspects and discourse techniques used in the news item. The news item highlights the formal processes and language used in legal affairs, emphasizing the need for legal experience and due process. Yet, the tone and framing of the news story may also affect how the general public understands the issue and the key players. To better understand complicated topics like the recent election crisis in Pakistan, it is vital to evaluate the wording and framing of news pieces.
According to a corpus-based analysis of news headlines, Pakistan is currently experiencing a crisis over the Chief Justice of Pakistan's authority (CJP). Several news outlets have covered the situation, framing it with different linguistic devices and discourse constructions.
First of all, the phrase "suo motu powers," "one-man show," and "clipping powers" are used in the news headlines to describe the problem. This language characteristic emphasizes the power dynamics at work, highlighting the concentration of power in the CJP's hands and the necessity of limiting his authority.
Second, different viewpoints on the subject are expressed in the news headlines through quotes from the Pakistani Prime Minister, judges, and legal professionals. Readers can hear from several stakeholders and get a complex knowledge of the topic thanks to this dialogue method.
thirdly, to catch the reader's attention and emphasize the gravity of the problem, news headlines utilize sensational language such as "scathing note destroys CJP's order" and "laments over political intolerance." This language characteristic emphasizes the impact of the crisis on Pakistan's political and legal environment and the urgency of taking immediate action.
Fourthly, legal documents and procedures are included in the news headlines, such as "bill to amend SC suo motu powers" and "notices served in plea against KPK, Punjab elections delay." The formal and procedural aspect of the crisis is highlighted by this linguistic trait, emphasizing the demand for legal knowledge and due procedure.
The analysis demonstrates that the CJP power crisis is a complex problem that has been presented in a variety of ways by various news sources. The language and discourse techniques utilized in news headlines reflect the conflicting power structures, the demand for legal competence and due process, and the crisis's urgency. To comprehend complex problems like the recent crisis in Pakistan better, it's vital to evaluate the wording and framing of news items.
Read more: Critical Discourse Analysis of Political Slogans in Pakistan
Sources:
https://www.thenews.com.pk/latest/1054929-cabinet-okays-bill-to-amend-sc-suo-motu-powers
https://www.thenews.com.pk/latest/1054890-mockery-has-been-made-of-constitution-today-pm-shehbaz
https://tribune.com.pk/story/2408620/cabinet-approves-bill-limiting-cjps-suo-motu-powers
https://www.dawn.com/news/1744648
Pakistan today:
Bill to ‘clip’ CJP’s suo moto powers lands in NA after cabinet’s approval
Daily Times:
SC serves notices in plea against KPK, Punjab elections delay